Overall Findings
The easiest way to summarize the difference between these two services is as follows: YouTube Premium combines the benefits of YouTube Music Premium with additional video features. Two big decisions will affect your choice. The first is whether you’re a big YouTube video watcher and how important that is to you, as YouTube Music Premium is… well, just music. The second is if you have children, as YouTube Premium has features to protect your kids.
Content: YouTube Music Premium Has Music Videos, YouTube Premium Has Even More
YouTube started as a video company, so naturally, the “umbrella” service includes this type of content. And not just the user-generated content for which YouTube became famous either. The company does produce some original content, although they’ve recently reduced their investment in this. In addition, this original content was previously exclusive to the premium service but is now available for free, albeit with ads. On the other hand, YouTube Music Premium only streams music, though it includes a broad catalog. In this respect, it’s comparable to other music streaming services. YouTube Music optionally plays music videos while playing their corresponding songs, but only when they’re available.
Benefits: Both Ad-Free & Available for Download, But YouTube Premium Also Protects Kids
Bearing in mind that YouTube Music Premium is music only, the two services share many of the same benefits compared to their free counterparts. Specifically, you can consume content without listening to ads, and you can download videos/songs for use when you don’t have a network connection. To a certain extent, it depends on whether YouTube’s recommendations suit your tastes better or worse than other services. Beyond these main features, there are two additional perks YouTube Premium offers. The first is YouTube Kids, an app that ensures the videos children watch are kid-friendly. The second is background play for videos, allowing the sound for videos to continue playing even when you switch to another app.
Cost: The ‘Upgrade’ to YouTube Premium Is a No-Brainer for Most
In contrast, YouTube Premium costs $11.99 per month ($17.99 for families). On the surface, it seems to be a comparable rate until you consider that this cost also includes all the same benefits as YouTube Music Premium. In essence, even if you’re interested primarily in music, you can also enjoy all the video-related benefits of YouTube Premium for just an additional two to three dollars a month.
Final Verdict
Unless you have some extraordinary circumstances, you should go for YouTube Premium. If you’re very sensitive to price and are indeed only interested in music, then getting just YouTube Music Premium will save you enough for an extra coffee each month. But since it includes everything YouTube Music Premium offers, the value over and above that service for just a couple of dollars a month makes it a no-brainer. It’s especially true if you often travel (you can download videos for offline viewing) or have children (YouTube Kids keeps them safe from dubious YouTube videos).
